The Voice of Andaman and Nicobar Islands
The Voice of Andaman and Nicobar Islands
/ month
placeholder text
Follow Us
placeholder text

Supreme Court Declines Immediate Hearing on Viral Video PIL Over Religious Remarks

Date:

New Delhi, July 6: The Supreme Court on Monday declined to grant an urgent hearing on a public interest litigation (PIL) seeking action over alleged derogatory remarks against Prophet Muhammad in a viral social media video, directing the petitioner to first pursue the available legal remedies through the police and other competent authorities.

A Bench comprising Justices Ahsanuddin Amanullah and Sheel Nagu refused the request for immediate listing when the matter was mentioned before the court. The Bench observed that the ordinary legal process should be followed before approaching the apex court under Article 32 of the Constitution.

During the hearing, the court said law enforcement authorities were responsible for addressing such complaints in the first instance and urged the petitioner to have confidence in the legal system. The Bench observed that if every grievance was brought directly before the Supreme Court, lower authorities would be unable to effectively perform their statutory responsibilities.

The court acknowledged the seriousness of the allegations but maintained that established legal procedures must be exhausted before the apex court intervenes. Justice Amanullah observed that while the issue was grave and sensitive, the petitioner should first pursue the remedies available under law and approach the Supreme Court only if those mechanisms failed.

The Bench also cautioned against sensationalising matters involving religious sentiments, observing that if an individual had committed an offence, legal action should be taken strictly in accordance with the law.

The PIL was filed under Article 32 by advocate-on-record Ansar Ahmad Chaudhari. The petition seeks directions to authorities to identify, remove and delete videos and social media posts allegedly containing defamatory and offensive remarks against Prophet Muhammad.

The petition also requests directions to the Union government to frame and implement guidelines governing the publication and dissemination of digital content allegedly intended to insult revered religious figures, including Prophet Muhammad and Bhagwan Shri Ram.

In addition, the petitioner has sought safeguards to prevent the alleged misuse of online platforms for content that could outrage religious sentiments or promote communal disharmony.

- Advertisement -

According to the petition, the grievance arises from a viral podcast clip in which respondent Nazia Elahi Khan allegedly made remarks concerning Prophet Muhammad that the petitioner claims hurt the religious sentiments of Muslims. The petition further alleges that the interviewer published the complete podcast despite having the opportunity to edit or remove the disputed portion.

The plea argues that while freedom of speech is protected under the Constitution, it remains subject to reasonable restrictions and does not extend to speech that allegedly targets revered religious figures in a manner capable of affecting public order and communal harmony.

The petition has named the Union Ministry of Home Affairs, the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, YouTube, Facebook, X and Nazia Elahi Khan among the respondents.

According to the case timeline attached to the petition, an FIR was registered in Mumbai on June 23 in connection with the alleged remarks, following which the PIL was filed before the Supreme Court on July 2.

Popular

More like this
Related

Supreme Court Rejects Tamil Nadu Plea for Additional Cauvery Water From Karnataka

Supreme Court rejects Tamil Nadu's plea directing Karnataka to release 26.954 tmcft of additional Cauvery water amid the continuing dispute.

Supreme Court Gives Niyamat Until January 7 to Respond in SC/ST Act Case

Supreme Court allows Aziz-ur-Rehman time until January 7 to respond to the Administration’s reply in the SC/ST Act case.

Supreme Court Airfare Case Puts Andaman’s Connectivity Crisis in Focus as Centre Finalises New Rules

The Centre has finalised airfare rules amid a Supreme Court PIL. Here is what the proposed regulations could mean for Andaman residents and air connectivity.

Supreme Court Issues Notice on Plea for Nationwide Safety Protocol for Women Police at Protests

The Supreme Court seeks the Centre’s response to a PIL seeking a nationwide protocol for women police safety, protest management and digital evidence verification.

Stay updated with the latest Andaman news and follow Andaman news today with timely updates from across the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. From breaking developments in Port Blair to important stories across South Andaman, North Andaman, and Nicobar, The Wave Andaman delivers clear, reliable coverage of the events shaping everyday life in the islands