New Delhi, Nov 18: A proposed demolition of a building identified as fugitive underworld figure Dawood Ibrahim’s ancestral property in south Mumbai has triggered a dispute over its legal status, with Congress MLA Amin Patel challenging the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation’s (BMC) move and citing previous court orders that he claims restrain the action.
The civic body has ordered the demolition of the dilapidated Musafirkhana building in Bhendi Bazaar, scheduling the operation for November 18 and 19 under heavy police protection. Patel has questioned the timing and legality of the action, maintaining that the Bombay High Court granted stays against earlier demolition orders in 2024 and 2025.
Speaking to IANS, the Congress legislator said the BMC had issued a demolition notice citing a 2020 High Court order. However, he claimed that subsequent judicial orders stayed the proposed demolition and that documents available with his legal team supported the continuation of the stay.

Patel also referred to proceedings before the Waqf Tribunal, where hearings are underway to determine whether the property belongs to the Waqf Board. He said the ownership dispute remains unresolved and should be decided through the appropriate legal process.
To support the claim that the building constitutes Waqf property, Patel cited gazette records dating to 1944. He also referred to BMC documents from 1991 that reportedly describe the premises as a mosque.
The MLA further claimed that the Supreme Court had directed that, if the property was in a dilapidated condition, the Waqf Board should undertake necessary repairs. He said the Waqf Tribunal had also referred to the Supreme Court’s stay while considering the matter.
Questioning the civic body’s decision to proceed with demolition within two days, Patel alleged that the BMC was disregarding judicial directions, the state government’s position and provisions of the Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act. He called for an inquiry into the conduct of the concerned civic official and demanded action if any wrongdoing emerged.
The proposed demolition has also drawn opposition from members of the Muslim community. Patel claimed that several people had stayed inside the mosque overnight to resist the action and warned that the dispute could affect law and order if the civic body proceeded.
He held the municipal corporation responsible for maintaining the situation and said those opposing the demolition were unwilling to vacate the premises.
The competing claims over the property’s ownership, the alleged judicial stays and the BMC’s demolition order remain central to the dispute.



